Big Picture Big Sound

2017 Oscar Nominees for Short Film - Live Action Review

By David Kempler

Silence Is Golden

DeKalb Elementary - (Reed Van Dyk)
The Silent Child - (Chris Overton and Rachel Shenton)
My Nephew Emmett - (Kevin Wilson Jr.)
The Eleven O'Clock - (Derin Seale and Josh Lawson)
Watu Wote/All of Us - (Katja Benrath and Tobias Rosen)

DeKalb Elementary Steven, a mentally unstable twentysomething, enters an elementary school with a semi-automatic rifle. After he orders the school receptionist, Cassandra, to have the building evacuated, he holds her hostage and instructs her to call 911. With Cassandra as his go-between, Steven tries to navigate the troubled waters he has entered. Timely, but only ordinary. 2.0 Stars

The Silent Child Libby, a profoundly deaf four-year-old, is the youngest child in a family who are all hearing. Unable to communicate but about to start school, Libby is assigned a social worker who teaches her sign language. Libby's skeptical parents are reluctant to be involved, however, and pose a potential block to Libby's education. It's poignant, sweet, and sad, and very well done. A definite contender to win. 3.5 StarsĀ 

The_Silent_Child2.jpg


My Nephew Emmett In 1955, two white men invade the home of Mose Wright, an African-American preacher in Mississippi, to abduct his 14-year-old nephew, Emmett Till, who is visiting from Chicago. Emmett has been accused of whistling at a white woman, and Mose knows that his fate will be sealed if the men succeed in taking him. A well-known story told as if you were there experiencing the terror firsthand. Solid but not special, but it could sneak in. 3.0 Stars

The Eleven O'Clock A psychiatrist earnestly tries to help his delusional patient, but his efforts are complicated by the fact that the patient believes himself to be the doctor. With each trying to out-analyze the other, their session spirals out of control. A one-joke joke that falls totally flat. 1.0 Stars

Watu Wote/All of Us. Jua, a Christian living in Kenya, boards a chartered bus to visit a relative and is uncomfortable being surrounded by Muslim passengers. The bus is stopped by the violent terrorist group Al-Shabaab, whose members demand that the Muslims identify the Christian passengers. Powerful and upsetting. Another contender 3.0 Stars

What did you think?

Movie title
Release year 2017
MPAA Rating NR
Our rating
Summary Three of the nominees have a chance of winning, but I'm going with the one that felt the most like a full-length film in terms of story development.
View all articles by David Kempler
More in Movies
Big News
Newsletter Sign-up
 
Connect with Us